The order in which players left the game, and the impact they left behind:
- Zane (Matsing) Another player begging to be voted out early.
- Roxy (Matsing) [...]
- Angie (Matsing) Don't talk about cookies, Angie. Makes you sound vacuous.
- Russell Swan (Matsing; Samoa) Don't be an idiotic leader, Russell. Makes you exit early even without having to be evacuated.
- Dana (Kalabaw) [...]
- Dawson (Kalabaw) Watch out, Jeff Probst!
- Katie (Kalabaw) [...]
- "RC" (Tandang) The victim of a tribemate making an even more baffling alliance shift than Kim last season.
- Jeff Kent (Kalabaw) Ballplayer outsmarted himself.
- Artis (Tandang) Apparently really didn't like Mike Skupin.
- Pete (Tandang) [...]
- Jonathan Penner (Kalabaw; Cook Islands) Outsmarted himself. Still deserves another chance to win. Let him and Coach and Ozzy play together on the same team, and one of them is bound to win...
- Carter (Kalabaw) Effective in challenges. Otherwise a nonentity.
- Abi (Tandang) The most oblivious villain in Survivor history.
- Malcolm (Matsing) Tremendous competitor. But buckles under the pressure.
- Lisa Whelchel (Tandang) Surprisingly effective in this game.
- Michael Skupin (Tandang; Australian Outback) Proved that he has what it takes to be competitive deep into the game.
- Denise (Matsing) Won because the jury couldn't bring itself to reward her competitors. Basically the Tina of this season.